20th Anniversary Logo Institute for Intellectual Property & Information Law

 

SPRING LECTURE

SPONSORED BY

Anrews Kurth

Christopher Jon Sprigman
Christopher Jon Sprigman
Professor of Law
New York University School of Law

Click here for Professor Sprigman's faculty listing

Copyright and Creative Incentives:
What We Know (And Don't)

Click here for the Spring Lecture Invitation

Thursday, March 30, 2017

5:30 P.M. RECEPTION
6:15 P.M. LECTURE

VENUE:

Coronado Club
919 MILAM - HOUSTON

To RSVP or for further information, contact
ipil@uh.edu or 713.743.2180
One Hour of CLE Credit

Chris Sprigman teaches intellectual property law, antitrust law, competition policy, and comparative constitutional law at New York University School of Law. His scholarship focuses on how legal rules affect innovation and the deployment of new technologies. He is the author of two books and of numerous articles, both in law reviews and in the popular press.

Sprigman received his B.A. with honors from the University of Pennsylvania in 1988. He attended the University of Chicago Law School, serving as a comment editor of the University of Chicago Law Review and graduating with honors in 1993. Following graduation, Sprigman clerked for Judge Stephen Reinhardt of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, and for Justice Lourens H. W. Ackermann of the Constitutional Court of South Africa. Sprigman also taught at the law school of the University of the Witwatersrand, in Johannesburg, South Africa.

From 1999 to 2001, Sprigman served as appellate counsel in the Antitrust Division of the U.S. Department of Justice, where he worked on U.S. v. Microsoft, among other matters. Sprigman then joined the Washington, D.C., office of King & Spalding, where he was elected a partner. In 2003, he left law practice to become a Residential Fellow at the Center for Internet and Society at Stanford Law School. He joined the University of Virginia faculty in 2005, and moved from UVA to NYU in 2013.

Selected publications include: THE KNOCKOFF ECONOMY: HOW IMITATION SPARKS INNOVATION (Oxford University Press, 2012) (with Kal Raustiala); Innovation Heuristics: Experiments on Sequential Creativity in Intellectual Property, 92 Ind. L.J. 1251 (2016) (with Christopher Buccafusco & Stefan Bechtold); Experimental Tests of Intellectual Property Laws' Creative Thresholds, 92 Tex. L. Rev. 1921 (2014) (with Christopher Buccafusco, Zachary C. Burns & Jeanne C. Fromer); Berne's Vanishing Ban on Formalities, 28 Berkeley Tech. L.J. 1565 (2013); and What's a Name Worth?: Experimental Tests of the Value of Attribution in Intellectual Property, 93 B.U. L. Rev. 1389 (2013) (with Buccafusco & Burns).

Copyright and Creative Incentives: What We Know (And Don't)

The grounding justification for copyright law is that the grant of exclusive rights in artistic and literary works will incentivize authors to invest in new creativity. The economic theory undergirding this justification is straightforward. By preventing competition from copyists, copyright law helps to ensure that the return (if any) generated by a particular act of artistic or literary creativity will flow to the author, and not to a copyist. The improved prospect of gain is expected to motivate additional creative effort.

This is an entirely sensible story, but is it right? On that foundational question we have mostly surmise, and little that qualifies as evidence. We have a small number of event studies designed to investigate copyright incentives. We also have a growing number of qualitative studies of copyright incentives in the branch of IP scholarship that some refer to as Intellectual Production Without Intellectual Property ("IP Without IP") and others as the "Negative Space" scholarship. And we have a very small number of lab experiments investigating copyright incentives.

Together, these scattered bits of empirical evidence suggest that the relationship between copyright and creativity is … complicated. We see data suggesting that copyright incentivizes some sorts of creativity sometimes. Other data suggests that in some settings copyright incentives may do little or nothing to encourage creative output. The as-yet incomplete account that is emerging calls to mind what Professor Fritz Machlup said about patents in a 1958 report to the United States Congress:

"If we did not have a patent system, it would be irresponsible on the basis of our present knowledge of its economic consequences, to recommend instituting one. But since we have had a patent system for a long time, it would be irresponsible on the basis of our present knowledge, to recommend abolishing it . . ."

This talk will highlight representative examples of the existing empirical scholarship on the relationship between copyright and creative incentives, assess how well the existing scholarship informs us regarding the supposed link between the two, and sketch out some of the directions future research should take to improve the state of our knowledge.

PRIOR LECTURERS

 

2017 CHRISTOPHER JON SPRIGMAN, Professor of Law, New York University School of Law
Copyright and Creative Incentives: What We Know (And Don't)
2017 CHRISTOPHER JON SPRIGMAN, Professor of Law, New York University School of Law
Copyright and Creative Incentives: What We Know (And Don't)

Commentator: Bob McAughan

Event Invitation

Event Photos

JEANNE FROMER2016 MARK LEMLEY, William H. Neukom Professor of Law, Stanford Law School
Rethinking Assignor Estoppel

Commentator: Ed Fein

Event Invitation

Event Photos

JEANNE FROMER2015 JEANNE FROMER, Professor of Law, New York University School of Law
Should the Law Care Why Intellectual Property Rights Have Been Asserted?

Commentator: Richard Phillips

Event Invitation

Event Photos

Julie CohenEvent Invitation2014 JULIE E. COHEN, Professor of Law, Georgetown University Law Center
Post-Industrial Property

Commentator: Bart Showalter

Event Photos

David McGowanEvent Invitation2013 DAVID MCGOWAN, Lyle L. Jones Professor of Competition & Innovation Law and Director, Center for Intellectual Property Law & Markets, University of San Diego School of Law
The Unfallen Sky: Assessing the Relative Effectiveness of Legal and Market Adaptations to Technological Change

 

Commentator: Jacqueline Lipton

Event Photos

R. Anthony ReeseEvent Invitation2012 R. ANTHONY REESE, Chancellor's Professor of Law, University of California - Irvine School of Law
What Does Copyright Law Owe the Future?

Commentator: Paul R. Morico

Event Photos

Paul GoldsteinEvent Invitation2011 PAUL GOLDSTEIN, Stella W. and Ira S. Lillick Professor of Law, Stanford Law School
Copyright on a Clean Slate

Commentator: Phillip Page

Event Photos

Douglas LichtmanEvent Invitation2010 DOUGLAS LICHTMAN, Professor of Law, University of California – Los Angeles School of Law
Pricing Patents: The RAND Commitment

 

Commentator: Gordon White

Event Photos

William O. HennesseyEvent Invitation2009 WILLIAM O. HENNESSEY, Professor of Law and Chair, Intellectual Property Graduate Programs, Franklin Pierce Law Center
Thirty Years (and More) of IP in China: A Personal Reflection

Commentator: Margaret (Meg) Boulware

Event Photos

Robert MergesEvent Invitation2008 ROBERT MERGES, Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati Professor of Law and Technology, Director, Berkeley Center for Law & Technology, University of California School of Law – Boalt Hall
The Concept of Property in the Digital Age

Event Photos

Commentator: Henry N. Garrana

 

Joel ReidenbergEvent Invitation2007 JOEL REIDENBERG, Professor of Law and Founding Director of the Center on Law and Information Policy, Fordham University School of Law
The Rule of Intellectual Property Law in the Internet Economy

Commentator: Jeff C. Dodd

Event Photos

Arthur GajarsaEvent Invitation2006 THE HONORABLE ARTHUR J. GAJARSA, United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
Patents in a Changing Economy Event Photos

Commentator: Scott F. Partridge

 

Scott KieffEvent Invitation2005 F. SCOTT KIEFF, Professor of Law, Washington University in St. Louis-School of Law
Theory & Practice in Commercializing Innovation

 

Commentator: John D. Norris

Event Photos

Jane GinsburgEvent Invitation2004 JANE C. GINSBURG, Morton L. Janklow Professor of Literary and Artistic Property Law, Columbia University School of Law School
The Right to Claim Authorship after Dastar

Commentator: Paul E. Krieger

Event Photos